Mike was very excited for this scene and for good reason. He starts nude lying down in his pool looking up at the camera before he receives a marshmallow fluff pie in his face from his Pie Mistress. She then unloads an entire can of shaving cream over Mike's face and proceeds to pie Mike with 5 big shaving cream pies, while he just lies there and takes it. As he gets pied Mike is made to count down some pies, thank his mistress for his punishment, admit that he is a pie slut and other less humiliating banter. (Mike even forgets how to count and loses track of how many times he has been pied). Before Mike pulls his head out of the mess he rolls his head from side to side.

Mike's pie punishment ends with him getting onto his knees and being slammed into the mess leftover from his pieing. Mike submissively asks for another so he gets his hair pulled for good measure and pushed back into the mess. Now that he has been thoroughly pied and humiliated Mike can't hold himself back any longer and has to roll onto his back so he can cover himself with the mess and grabs his cock. Mike spends over 10 minutes lying on his back and masturbating while alternating between rubbing the mess into his body or piling the mess onto his face and head. Mike does bring himself to orgasm on camera moaning for his mistress as he does so.